While NFL Network commentator Troy Aikman agreed the play was a penalty — Young landed on Jones with his body weight — several people on social media felt otherwise, including former NFL offensive lineman Geoff Schwartz: 

MORE: Giants-Washington live updates, highlights

Savid Deen, who covers the Dolphins for the South Florida Sun Sentinel, also commented negatively, as did CBS Sports senior NFL writer Will Brinson: 

MORE: When will WFT pick a new team name?

More comments from the Twitter community: 

Despite his penalty, Young had two tackles and half a sack after the first quarter. The Giants led 10-7 late in the first half. 

MORE: Giants lineman Nick Gates suffers gruesome leg injury vs. Washington